Out of the mouths of babes, literally...”Grandma says that if you think you’ve added enough cinnamon, you HAVEN’T—add more!” That’s the secret to the best ever apple pie.
Re-posting from a few years ago, one of my family faves, and now the grandkids help! Well, one of them does…the other one is just like his dad and waits until it’s baked so he can eat it.
Your apple pie tutorial. An apple pie with attitude.
If you are one of the many boys and girls (OK, adults) who’ve never made an apple pie from scratch and you don’t want to meet the Grim Reaper without having made at least one perfect apple pie, you’ve come to the right place.
I’m right here, holding your hand, gently walking you through all the steps and twists and turns to create the best apple pie you will ever eat. Guaranteed.
I know you can do it! Once you’ve mastered one pie start to finish, you will never be afraid of a little old piecrust again. Pinky swear.
The Apples
The apples you choose are of the utmost importance. They need to be firm and tart and able to stand up to the heat of a 425 degree oven without becoming mushy as the pie bakes.
I like Granny Smith or Pippin apples for pies. Normally, that would be the green ones. Depending on the size of the apple, I like to use between 6-8 apples per pie.
I enjoy making my pies the old fashioned way. I peel and slice the apples.
Squeeze a little lemon juice over the slices for a pop of flavor and it’ll help keep the apples from turning brown. Unless I’m making apple jelly, I put the peels in the compost bin, and so should you!
This is one time when I use white sugar and don’t feel guilty about it–about 1/2 cup or to taste. Some apples need more sweetness, some need less.
The most important ingredient is cinnamon. The right amount of cinnamon elevates the apple pie to a higher level. I use approximately 3-4 tablespoons. The kids (and dad) do a lot of tasting, so it’s a good idea to add a little at a time and taste as you go. We love a LOT of cinnamon!
When you feel that your apples and sugar and cinnamon have reached the zenith of blissful co-existence, sprinkle one tablespoon all-purpose flour over the apples and mix lightly.
Don’t be afraid, don’t desert me before the dessert is complete–watch and learn!
I like my mom’s favorite cookbook for old-fashioned recipes.
It’s not that difficult. It’s like many things in life. Once you try something new and master it, you lose the fear of the unknown.
The Crust
It’s not rocket science. This is a tried and true basic recipe for a two-crust pie. I don’t like to use butter in this crust because I don’t want any other flavors to ruin the apple+cinnamon perfection. I know you can use a food processor and it cuts the time in half but sometimes the most satisfying part of baking is to be fully immersed in the process as much as the final results!
For a nine-inch pie pan:
Mix together…
2 cups all purpose flour
3/4 teaspoons salt
Cut in…
2/3 cup shortening (This is one and only recipe where I use Crisco)
Sprinkle with…
Four tablespoons water (more if necessary)
What does “cut in” mean? It means you need to distribute the shortening into the flour so that the particles become the size of peas. This is what makes pastry flaky. Use a pastry blender to cut shortening into flour. If you don’t have one, use two knives and this technique: holding a knife in each hand with blades almost touching, move knives back and forth in opposite directions in a parallel cutting motion. The side of a fork or a wire whisk works, too.
Mix only until all ingredients are worked in. If you overwork pastry dough, it’ll become tough. Sprinkle the water in a tablespoon at a time, mixing lightly with a fork until all the flour is moistened. Gather dough together and press into two balls for the upper and bottom crust.
At this point, if you have time, cover and chill for about thirty minutes or so.
Flour the board or counter and the rolling pin so the dough won’t stick. There are all kinds of fancy schmancy rolling pins–I’ve been really happy with this old wooden one. Flatten the balls with your hand. Roll each ball into a sort of circle; don’t go all crazy thinking it has to be perfect at this point. If it breaks or tears, just pinch and push it back together–about 1/8 inch thick. For an apple pie, I think the bottom crust needs to be a bit more sturdy than the top crust, and roll into a circle two inches larger than pie plate.
Pile high with the yummy apples.
Redo the same steps with the other round for the top crust. Cut off the extra dough that hangs over–leaving enough to fold under.
You can either crimp the edges…or use a fork. Dip fork tines in flour; press tines onto edge of dough. Poke with fork or knife all around to release steam as it bakes.
I wanted to add an enchanted seashell embellishment to the final version.
I molded leftover dough over a scallop shell, cut off the excess, and placed it on the pie.
It will bake quicker than the pie–remember to take it out after about ten minutes and place it back on the pie before serving.
I always bake pies on a cookie sheet because they will invariably ooze and turn your oven into a burning, sticky, smoky mess that can set off a smoke alarm and that’s always annoying!
Bake at 425 degrees for about 45 minutes or so until it’s bubbly and the crust is beautifully browned, long enough so that the bottom crust is completely baked and not soggy.
The Finished Product
Yummy!
Most photos by Enchanted Seashells
Enchanted Seashells | Princess Rosebud 